Positive Thoughts

Why This Trans Guy Stopped Taking Daily PrEP for HIV Prevention

Listen to this article

By JD Davids


I’m not stopping PrEP because my skin turned blue. That was an embarrassing mistake in the first few days of trying it. Don’t tell anyone, though, or they’ll find out that I’m the kind of guy who buys a black flannel shirt and wears it for a few days without washing it, not realizing it’s going to seep dye onto any exposed areas and causing me to make panicky calls to bemused, sympathetic friends and globally-noted HIV researchers alike.

And it’s not because I got an itchy-burny rash on my neck and face after my very first pill. I get a lot of side effects and know they are usually transient. But just to be sure, I waited till I could see an allergist. He agreed that it was not a dangerous reaction, so with my primary care provider’s blessing I took a half-pill daily, along with an over-the-counter allergy med, for 10 days before retrying the whole pill.

And it’s certainly not because anything has come out in the last year and half that I’ve been on it that has me questioning its efficacy. To the contrary, around the world there’s been only three outlier cases of people acquiring HIV despite daily PrEP use: two people who encountered relatively rare resistant strains, and one person who had a rather high number of partners and an unusual configuration of HIV antibodies when he tested positive – and all are doing really well on treatment, at last report.

I’ve been following PrEP research for, wow, decades now, back when a potential compound was still being studied in animals for protective activity while researchers speculated that the protective effects of treating pregnant people with HIV to lower transmission rates to babies could maybe work for sex as well.

I’d cried when the results came out from that study of birth parents and babies in 1993, and I cried again when I heard the trial results in 2010 confirming PrEP was a home run. But I didn’t consider myself as a PrEP candidate until a few years ago, when a partner was taking the next steps in his own gender transition and feeling more confident in making moves on cis men.

As I stepped into the role of authoritative HIV geek explaining how PrEP might help him feel more comfortable as a bottom, I found myself thinking, “Well, damn, that does sound pretty good,” and realized I wanted in on it myself. So I did, and became one of growing numbers of people who found PrEP to be good for more than just HIV prevention, as it helped me grow into my understanding and embodiment of my gender, my desire and my identity.

But in my current configuration of relationships and adventure (including reborn appreciation for “female” condoms and deep delight that HIV undetectable equals untransmittable (U=U)), I’m not putting this PrEP to much use these days.

Dr. Bob Grant, who knows as much about PrEP as anyone (in addition to being a hell of a nice guy who was, um, kind to me when I called him when I turned blue), likes to talk about PrEP as a tool for those of us in “seasons of risk”:


Taking antiretrovirals for PrEP is different from taking them for HIV treatment, in significant ways. Treatment for HIV is something people need to start early and stick with long term. PrEP is different. People go through “seasons of risk,” periods of their lives when they are at risk for acquiring HIV, and PrEP is appropriate for those times. In periods when they have negotiated safety with a partner or they’re just not having much sex, they may find they don’t need PrEP. It’s actually appropriate that some people stop PrEP, because they’re in a different phase of their life and they no longer need it.


I’ve found myself taking PrEP for weeks or months without having any real risk of HIV, so clearly it seemed seasons have changed. I take lots of meds and supplements for three autoimmune diseases and related chronic pain and fatigue – so I’m good with having one less pill and two less drugs in the mix.

Plus, it now looks like it will be easier than previously thought for me to get up to protective levels if I want to get back on. Here’s the deal:

Current guidelines in the U.S. advise waiting for seven days of daily PrEP dosing to be fully covered for receptive anal sex; though four days per week may be sufficient, it may be that daily dosing can ensure the best shot at ongoing adherence and full coverage.

But I’m trans, and for me (though not for all transmasculine people, of course) that means I’ve got another active area that needs coverage.

As Roger Pebody reports on our site, “the U.S Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) continues to say that people need 20 days of daily TDF/FTC before they can consider themselves protected from vaginal HIV exposure – but the World Health Organization (WHO) has stated that just seven days of the drug is enough.”

I’m going with WHO for this one, at least for myself. That feels like a feasible strategy for me, as far as jumping back on PrEP a week before a trip or otherwise anticipated opportunity for good times.

All along, I’ve been at relatively low risk for HIV infection. But as someone who has been in the thick of HIV stuff for most of my life at this point, it felt incredible – and in some ways, necessary – to be at virtually zero HIV risk to fully open up to my desires and live into this phase of my life.

There’s a lot out there right now to help people get onto PrEP in the United States, no matter what the reason for their season. There’s tools for providers and patients and growing options like telemedicine or online ordering for those in remote locales or challenging circumstances.


If you think you don’t have HIV and you think you might want to give it a whirl, go for it. But if you find yourself turning blue, head to the laundromat first.


JD Davids is the director of partnerships and a senior editor at TheBody.com and TheBodyPRO.com. This column is a project of Plus, Positively Aware, POZ, The Body and Q Syndicate, the LGBT wire service. Visit their websites – http://hivplusmag.com, http://positivelyaware.com, http://poz.com and http://thebody.com – for the latest updates on HIV/AIDS.

Related Articles

Back to top button