This week’s column comes to you from both the “But People Can Change” department and the “Yeah, But No” department.
Think back to who you were an undergrad. I’m going to make an educated guess and say that you were insufferable. Granted, you were probably the sexiest you’ve ever been even though you ate pizza for breakfast, lunch and dinner most days. But you likely thought you knew everything. And that’s annoying.
If you’re reading this thinking, “But I was a genius 18-to-21-year-old with no flaws and incredibly humble to boot”, my response is to do some introspection. Maybe yoga will help.
Anyway, I have no doubt that I wrote things when I was an undergrad that would make me cringe today. Thankfully, those years took place at the infancy of the digital renaissance, and so most of that work is lost to history, and likely for the best.
That said, a short story I wrote in high school did recently end up on the internet, so I guess no one is ever safe.
The thing is, when I was in college I wasn’t making grand pronouncements about how gay people were disgusting and awful. Granted, I was a gay person, so maybe that doesn’t count. Still, there’s a difference between writing bad poetry or an impassioned diatribe against rape culture via a compare-and-contrast paper about the Porky’s and American Pie movies (one stellar observation that I can remember: ’80’s movie nudity contained cellulite). But if those writings surfaced I wouldn’t be like, “Oh, wow. I hurt people.”
The same cannot be said for Marc Short, Vice President Mike Pence’s new chief of staff, who wrote super homophobic garbage when he was in college and published it in the March 1992 issue of The Spectator, the conservative college paper he helped found. The front cover of that issue contains a “teaser” that reads: “AIDS: Who Gets It?”
The essay inside is called “AIDS and the Heterosexual” and it is vile. The gist of the essay is that heterosexuals can’t get AIDS, only gay people can, and trying to get heterosexuals to care about AIDS is all a part of a big gay plot to both get money from Congress and “de-stigmatize the perverted lifestyles homosexuals pursue.”
That is one hell of a plan. I mean so many gay men died horrible deaths while the Reagan administration basically laughed it off and the first Bush administration was hardly better. Call me crazy, but if there was really an organized and coordinated homosexual agenda I kind of doubt everybody agreed on “let’s die off” as an effective strategy.
Short also claimed that homosexuals were excited that Magic Johnson got AIDS since it helped them further the myth that straight people could get it, too. He also railed against “sodomites” getting “preferential treatment”, and by “treatment” he meant any government funding for the disease.
But it’s not as if a senior in college Short was unfeeling.
“Naturally we feel sympathy for … all AIDS victims,” he wrote, “but that does not mean we glorify homosexuals repugnant practices of frequent anal intercourse nor should we consider them brave for coming out of the closet.”
Got it. Homosexuals grossed Short out and the penalty for grossing Short out should be death.
But what does grown-up Marc Short have to say about all of this?
“I regret using language as an undergraduate college student that was not reflective of the respect I try to show others today,” he told The Daily Beast. “We have all learned a lot about AIDS over the past 30 years and my heart goes out to all the victims of this terrible disease.”
The subhead of The Daily Beast’s piece read that Short expressed “regret for words he says are no longer reflective of his worldview.” Perhaps there was more to the statement Short gave them, but when I read the part they quoted, which I have included above, that is not what Short means. He said he regrets being disrespectful. He doesn’t say that his worldview no longer sees homosexuals as sodomites deserving of death.
And here’s the thing: It’s hard to believe that Short is such a new and improved man considering for whom he works. Mike Pence is anti-LGBTQ through and through. He has been “Creep of the Week” many times for good reason.
Pence’s leadership and empathy failures dealing with AIDS as governor of Indiana is well-documented. The Trump Administration’s approach to AIDS nationally and globally seems more interested in shaming people than in saving lives.
So, yeah, no. If Short wants anyone to believe that he no longer believes the garbage he wrote about AIDS, then he should maybe consider working for people who aren’t currently operating under the those same garbage ideas.
D’Anne Witkowski is a poet, writer and comedian living in Michigan with her wife and son. She has been writing about LGBT politics for over a decade. Follow her on Twitter @MamaDWitkowski.